Every spring, gardeners walk into seed displays or browse online catalogs and make the same expensive mistake: they buy way too many seeds based on emotion instead of math.
You see “Heirloom Tomato Collection, 12 Varieties!” and think that sounds amazing. You grab three different types of lettuce because you can’t decide which one you want. You buy a packet of 200 carrot seeds for a 4-foot row that only needs 50 seeds. Six months later, you have a drawer full of half-used seed packets you’ll probably never finish.
Here’s the reality: most seed packets contain far more seeds than a home gardener needs. And most gardeners buy more varieties than they have space to grow. The result is wasted money on seeds you’ll never plant, or planting everything and creating an overcrowded mess.
Let’s fix this by teaching you to buy seeds strategically based on actual space, realistic plant counts, and seed viability.
The Core Problem: Seed Packets Contain Too Many Seeds
Commercial seed packets are sized for market gardens and serious home growers, not beginners with a single 4×8 raised bed.
Here’s what you actually get:
Tomatoes: 25-50 seeds per packet. You probably want 3-6 plants total. That’s 6-10 seeds planted (assuming some don’t germinate). You’ll use 20-25% of the packet.
Lettuce: 500-1,000 seeds per packet. Even with succession planting every two weeks all season, you might plant 100-150 seeds. You’ll use 10-20% of the packet.
Carrots: 500-2,000 seeds per packet. A 4-foot row needs about 50-60 seeds. Even with multiple plantings, you might use 200 seeds total. You’ll use 10-30% of the packet.
Beans: 50-150 seeds per packet. A typical planting is 20-30 seeds for a small bed. You’ll use 20-40% of the packet.
Cucumbers: 20-30 seeds per packet. You probably want 2-4 plants. You’ll use 10-20% of the packet.
The pattern: Most packets contain 3-10x more seeds than a small home garden needs, even accounting for germination failure and succession planting.
Why This Becomes a Money Problem
Seed packets aren’t expensive individually, $2-5 for most varieties. But the costs add up fast when you’re buying 15-20 packets you’ll barely use.
The typical first-year seed buying spree:
- 5 tomato varieties: $15
- 3 pepper varieties: $12
- 3 types of lettuce: $9
- 2 cucumber varieties: $6
- 3 types of beans: $9
- Various herbs (6 packets): $18
- Squash, radishes, carrots (4 packets): $12
Total: $81 for seeds you’ll only use 10-30% of this year.
The smarter approach would cost $25-35 by buying single packets of each plant type and varieties you’ll actually grow multiples of.
The Variety Trap: More Isn’t Better
The seed display has eight types of tomatoes. They all sound good. You buy four different varieties because you can’t decide, thinking “I’ll just plant them all.”
Here’s what happens:
You need space for 4-6 tomato plants total in your garden. You planted four varieties, which means either:
Option 1: You plant one plant of each variety. Now you have four different tomatoes producing at different times with different characteristics. You can’t learn which variety actually performs best in your conditions because you only have one plant as a sample size. Plus, you’re eating four types of tomatoes in small quantities instead of enjoying abundance of one great variety.
Option 2: You plant multiple plants of each variety. Now you have 12-16 tomato plants in a space designed for 6. Everything is overcrowded, competing for resources, and producing poorly. You’re overwhelmed with harvest and can’t keep up.
The lesson: More varieties sounds exciting but creates practical problems. Choose 1-2 varieties you’re genuinely interested in and plant multiple plants of each. This gives you enough harvest to actually enjoy, room to grow them properly, and data to decide if that variety works for you.
How to Actually Calculate What You Need
Before buying any seeds, answer these questions:
Question 1: How many plants do I have space for?
Measure your garden space. Look up spacing requirements for each crop. Do the math.
Example: 4×8 bed (32 square feet)
- Tomatoes need 4 square feet each = room for 6-8 plants maximum
- Lettuce needs 1 square foot each = room for 20-30 plants with succession planting
- Beans need 4-6 inches between plants = room for 40-50 plants
Question 2: How many plantings will I do?
Some crops you plant once (tomatoes). Others you succession plant every 2-3 weeks (lettuce, beans, radishes).
One planting = buy seeds for that number plus 20% for germination failure.
Multiple plantings = multiply by number of plantings, then add 20%.
Question 3: What’s my germination rate assumption?
Fresh seeds from reputable companies typically have 80-95% germination rates. Build in some failure.
If you want 6 tomato plants, plant 8 seeds (75% success rate gives you 6 plants).
If you want 30 lettuce plants, plant 35-40 seeds (assuming 85-90% germination).
Question 4: Will I save seeds for next year?
If yes, buy slightly more. If no, buy exactly what you need for this season.
The formula: (Plants needed) × (Number of plantings) × 1.2 (for 20% failure buffer) = Seeds to buy
Example calculation for beans:
Want: 20 bean plants per planting Plantings: 2 (one in June, one in July) Calculation: 20 × 2 × 1.2 = 48 seeds needed
Most bean packets contain 50-100 seeds. Buy one packet, use half this year, save the rest for next year.
The Right Way to Buy Seeds
Step 1: Make a list of what you’re actually planting. Not what sounds interesting, what you have space for and will realistically grow.
Step 2: Choose ONE variety per crop type. Not three types of tomatoes, one tomato variety. Not two kinds of cucumbers, one cucumber variety. You can experiment with different varieties next year after you learn what works.
Step 3: Calculate how many plants you need of each variety.
Step 4: Buy the minimum number of packets to meet that need.
For most crops with large seed counts (lettuce, carrots, radishes), one packet is plenty for 2-3 years. For crops with smaller seed counts (tomatoes, peppers, cucumbers), one packet covers 2-5 years of small-scale planting.
Step 5: Resist impulse additions. Stick to your list. That beautiful seed packet display is designed to make you buy more than you need.
When It Makes Sense to Buy More Varieties
You should buy multiple varieties if:
You have space to properly trial them. If you have room for 12 tomato plants, buying 3 varieties and planting 4 of each makes sense. You’ll get meaningful data on which performs best.
You’re specifically comparing traits. Want to know if cherry tomatoes or beefsteak varieties work better in your garden? Buy both and plant equal numbers. Now you have useful comparison data for next year.
You’re succession planting different varieties intentionally. Some gardeners plant early, mid-season, and late varieties of the same crop to extend harvest. This requires multiple varieties and makes strategic sense.
You’re growing enough volume to make variety matter. If you’re planting 50+ lettuce plants over the season, having 2-3 varieties gives you salad diversity. If you’re only planting 20 lettuce plants total, one variety is plenty.
Otherwise, stick to one well-chosen variety per crop. Master it, learn its quirks, get good at growing it. Expand to new varieties next year.
The Seed Viability Factor
Most gardeners don’t realize that many seeds stay viable for years if stored properly. You don’t need to buy fresh seeds annually for everything.
Seed viability by crop:
1-2 years:
- Onions, parsnips, parsley (buy fresh each year)
- Corn (viability drops fast)
3-4 years:
- Beans, peas
- Carrots, parsnips
- Leeks, peppers
4-5 years:
- Brassicas (broccoli, cabbage, kale)
- Beets, chard
- Tomatoes, eggplant
- Lettuce, radishes
- Squash, cucumbers, melons
5+ years:
- Some tomato varieties (can last 7-10 years)
- Certain flowers and herbs
Storage conditions matter. Keep seeds in a cool, dry, dark place. A sealed container in the refrigerator is ideal. Room temperature in a drawer works fine for most seeds. Humid sheds or garages shorten viability significantly.
What this means for buying: That packet of tomato seeds you buy this year can supply your garden for 3-5 years if you’re only growing 6-8 plants annually. One $3 packet replaces $15-20 worth of repeated annual purchases.
The Alternative: Seed Sharing and Splitting
If you only need 20% of a seed packet, find someone who’ll use the other 80%.
Seed swaps: Many communities have seed swap events where gardeners trade packets. You might trade your excess carrot seeds for someone’s extra basil seeds.
Split with a friend: Buy packets together and divide them. You each get what you need at half the cost.
Join a seed library: Some public libraries now have seed libraries where you “check out” seeds, grow them, and return seeds from your harvest. Free seeds and built-in variety.
Online seed trading: Forums and Facebook groups dedicated to seed trading. Mail excess seeds to other gardeners in exchange for varieties you want.
This works especially well for expensive specialty seeds where a single packet might cost $6-8. Split it three ways with friends and you each pay $2-3.
What About Those “Variety Packs”?
Seed companies sell variety packs: “10 Types of Tomatoes!” or “Heirloom Lettuce Collection!”
When they make sense:
- You have lots of space and genuinely want variety
- Multiple gardeners are splitting the pack
- You’re specifically experimenting to find favorite varieties
When they’re a waste:
- You have limited space (under 100 square feet)
- You’re a first-year gardener still learning basics
- You just want a good tomato, not ten mediocre experiments
The reality: Variety packs seem like good value (more varieties for less money), but you’ll only seriously grow 2-3 of those varieties. The others will sit unused or get planted once out of guilt and take up space you needed for crops you actually want.
The “Just Buy What You’ll Use This Year” Strategy
Here’s a radical approach: only buy seeds you’ll plant this season. Don’t stockpile for future years.
Advantages:
- Spend less money upfront
- No seed storage concerns
- Always planting fresh, high-viability seeds
- No guilt about unused packets
Disadvantages:
- Pay full packet price each year even though you only use 20%
- Might not find your favorite variety next year if company stops carrying it
- Shipping costs if ordering online (might be more than seed costs)
Who this works for: Gardeners who grow 3-5 different crops with minimal variety experimentation. Gardeners who buy seeds locally without shipping costs.
Who should stockpile: Gardeners growing many different crops who’ll work through seed packets over multiple years. Gardeners in remote areas where seed shopping is inconvenient.
How to Store Unused Seeds Properly
If you’re keeping seeds for future years, store them right or they’ll lose viability.
The three enemies of seed viability:
- Heat (shortens life significantly)
- Moisture (causes premature germination or rot)
- Light (degrades some seeds)
Proper storage:
- Keep packets in an airtight container (plastic bin, glass jar, or sealed bag)
- Add a silica gel packet to absorb moisture
- Store in a cool location (refrigerator is ideal, cool closet works)
- Label packets with purchase year so you know age
Don’t:
- Leave packets in a hot garage or shed
- Store in humid basements
- Keep in direct sunlight
- Leave packets open to air exposure
Simple system: Buy a small plastic bin with a lid. Throw in a few silica gel packets (they come with shoes and electronics, save them). Store all seed packets in the bin. Keep it in a closet or refrigerator. Done.
The Real Cost of Buying Too Many Seeds
It’s not just the money spent on seeds you won’t use. It’s:
Overcrowded gardens because you felt obligated to plant everything you bought
Analysis paralysis next spring when you have 20 seed packets and can’t decide what to actually plant
Guilt every time you see those unopened packets
Wasted varieties you tried once, didn’t like, but bought a full packet of
Lost money on seeds that expired before you used them
The fix is simple: Buy less. Buy strategically. Use what you buy. Avoid the “more is better” trap that seed displays encourage.
Conclusion
The seed buying mistake that costs gardeners money every year isn’t buying expensive specialty seeds, it’s buying too many varieties, too many packets, and not calculating actual needs before purchasing.
One packet of most seeds contains enough for 3-5 years of small-scale gardening. One variety per crop is enough for first-year gardeners to succeed. More varieties sound exciting but create practical problems in limited space.
Before buying seeds this year, calculate how many plants you actually have room for. Choose one excellent variety per crop. Buy the minimum packets needed. Resist the urge to accumulate every interesting variety you see. Your garden will be less crowded, your seed budget will shrink, and you’ll actually use what you buy.
Key Takeaways
- Most seed packets contain 3-10x more seeds than small gardens need: one tomato packet has 25-50 seeds but you probably want 6 plants
- Calculate plants needed before buying: (plants wanted) × (plantings) × 1.2 = seeds needed: math prevents overbuying
- Choose one variety per crop for your first year: multiple varieties create overcrowding and confusion in small spaces
- Many seeds stay viable 3-5 years if stored properly: one packet can supply multiple years of planting
- Buying multiple varieties only makes sense with space to trial them properly: need 4+ plants per variety for meaningful data
- Variety packs waste money unless you have 100+ square feet and genuinely want diversity: you’ll only grow 2-3 varieties seriously
- Store unused seeds in airtight containers in cool, dry, dark locations: refrigerator is ideal, room temperature closet works
- Seed sharing and splitting packets with friends cuts costs: especially valuable for expensive specialty seeds
- Resist seed display impulse buying: stick to your calculated list based on actual space
- One excellent variety grown well beats three mediocre varieties grown poorly: focus beats variety in limited spaces
Leave a Reply